Urban Health Scare: E-Scooters Show Alarming Spike in Injuries
Hospital Admissions Quadrupled in Last Four Years, UCSF Study Finds, Mainly in Young Adults
Electric scooters are increasingly part of the crowded urban landscape, but a UC San Francisco study has found a major surge of injuries related to scooters, particularly among young adults.
The number of scooter-related injuries and hospital admissions in the United States grew by 222 percent between 2014 and 2018 to more than 39,000 injuries, while the number of hospital admissions soared by 365 percent to a total of nearly 3,300, according to the study.
Nearly a third of the patients suffered head trauma — more than twice the rate of head injuries to bicyclists. About a third of the e-scooter injuries were to women, and people between the ages of 18 and 34 were the most often injured for the first time in 2018.
The study appears Jan. 8, 2020 in JAMA Surgery.
“E scooters are a fast and convenient form of transportation and help to lessen traffic congestion, especially in dense, high-traffic areas,” said senior and corresponding author Benjamin N. Breyer, MD, a UCSF Health urologist. “But we’re very concerned about the significant increase in injuries and hospital admissions that we documented, particularly during the last year, and especially with young people, where the proportion of hospital admissions increased 354 percent.”
The UCSF team had previously looked at bicycle injuries using the same data set and found scooter riders had a higher proportion of head injuries, which was also identified in this study.
“There was a high proportion of people with head injuries, which can be very dangerous,” said Breyer, an associate professor of urology and chief of urology at UCSF partner hospital Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital and Trauma Center. “Altogether, the near doubling of e-scooter trauma from 2017 to 2018 indicates that there should be better rider safety measures and regulation.”
As motorized scooters have become more ubiquitous in the last few years, particularly within the country’s biggest cities and suburbs, health officials and medical experts across the country grew increasingly alarmed by the number of fractures, dislocations and head injuries appearing in trauma centers. Regulatory oversight is largely absent about where people can ride scooters and whether helmets are mandatory: Previous research showed that only a fraction of injured e-scooter riders (ranging from 2 to about 5 percent) wore helmets when they were hurt.
In the new study, the UCSF researchers used data from the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System on national estimates of injuries related to emergency room visits.
They found that a total of nearly 40,000 injuries occurred from powered scooters in the U.S. between 2014 and 2018. The study found that the rate of scooter accidents also increased, from 6 per 100,000 people in 2014 to 19 per 100,000 in 2018. The most common injuries were fractures (27 percent), contusions and abrasions (23 percent), and lacerations (14 percent).
Over the study period, urban hospitals received the highest proportion of patients (78 percent) compared to rural (20 percent) and children’s hospitals (2 percent).
The authors note that the actual incidence of e-scooter trauma may be underestimated because cases with unclear scooter types were excluded from the study, and some riders likely did not go to the emergency department despite their injuries. Future research into pedestrian and cyclist trauma associated with e-scooter use is needed, the authors said.
“It’s been shown that helmet use is associated with a lower risk of head injury,” said first author Nikan K. Namiri, medical student at the UCSF School of Medicine. “We strongly believe that helmets should be worn, and e-scooter manufacturers should encourage helmet use by making them more easily accessible.”
Authors: Co-authors are Hansen Lui and Thomas Tangney, both with the UCSF Department of Urology; Isabel E. Allen, PhD, with the UCSF Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics; and Andrew J. Cohen, MD, a former clinical instructor at the UCSF Department of Urology who is now an assistant professor at the Brady Urological Institute at Johns Hopkins Medicine.
Funding: The project was supported by an unrestricted gift from Bay Area philanthropists Anita and Kevan Del Grande. The authors cite no conflicts of interest.
Categories: Press Release